Dollars in,
dollars out
The director of one private
company told the Tien Phong reporters that he converts
all the firm’s income into dollars and deposits these into the bank.
Keeping cash assets in dollars has turned out to be safest bet in an era
of high dong inflation.
Thanh, an office worker,
also admitted she keeps only two kinds of assets, dollars and gold. “I
have the telephone numbers of five places where, if I need to buy
dollars, they will deliver to my door immediately,” she said.
Asked what she will do if
the Vietnam dong deposit interest rates rise very high while the
interest paid on dollar deposits rates drops dramatically, Thanh
maintained that she would still hold dollars.
A senior executive of the
Bank for Investment and Development (BIDV) said neither case is unusual. Many depositors prefer to hold cash in dollars,
clinging to the greenback even when the Vietnam dong interest rate
was sky high, 19 percent per annum, at the end of 2007. “People fear
high inflation and the fluctuation of the dong/dollar rate,” he said.
The director of a big bank
said the activities of commercial banks are exacerbating the
dollarization process. The
Foreign Currency Management Ordinance allows Vietnamese citizens to
deposit foreign currencies at credit institutions and get back both
principal and interest in the same foreign currencies. Banks
are happy to oblige. “The regulation itself encourages people to keep
dollars and deposit them into bank accounts, thus helping make the
dollarisation more serious.”
According to another
expert, the Ordinance should be amended to stipulate that people can
deposit in foreign currencies, but they may only withdraw Vietnam dong. That, he thinks, would deflate a black market that’s
booming because people are rushing to buy dollars to deposit at banks. If they could only withdraw dong, said the expert,
the foreign currency shortage of 2009 would never have occurred.
Should the
rules be changed?
Nguyen Thu Ha, a Deputy
General Director of Vietcombank, recalled that not so long ago, the law
allowed people to deposit foreign currency only for a credit in Vietnam
dong.
“I agree that the the
liberalization of the foreign currency regimne is one of the factors
that has made dollarization become more serious,” Ha said. However, she
pointed out, if Vietnam does not allow people to deposit and withdraw
money in foreign currencies, it will not be able to attract dollar
remittances, a very important source of capital, to the nation.
It is clear that the
regulation has encouraged one and all to purchase, trade and keep
dollars, comment the Tien Phong reporters. All sorts of enterprises, both public and private, hunt
for dollars. If they are able to earn dollars
from export contracts, they avoid selling them to banks in exchange for
dong.
Analysts have also pointed
out that Ordinance is internally contradictory. On
one hand, it allows people to withdraw money in dollars and hold
dollars, but on the other hand, it forbids them to use the dollar to
make transactions within the country.
The State Bank of Vietnam’s
target is to reduce the dollarization of the national economy to 15
percent by 2010. However, it appears that in fact the trend is the other
way. The amount of dollars deposited at banks in
Hanoi and HCM City has been increasing steadily over the last few
years.